Is That Even Legal? — 7+ Fall Scarecrow Ideas That Are Making Waves

As an Amazon, ShareASale and Impact Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. This means that if you click on a link in our blog and purchase an item from Amazon or any of the ShareASale & Impact partners, we receive an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. This helps us keep our content free and continue to provide valuable information. Thank you for your support! Read our full disclosure here

So, you think decorating for fall is all about pumpkins and leaves? Think again! This year, scarecrows are taking over in the most creative, wild, and—honestly—kinda weird ways.

We’re talking scarecrows that will have your neighbors doing double-takes, wondering, “Is that even legal?” From spooky to hilarious, these 50 Fall Scarecrow Ideas are guaranteed to make your yard the coolest on the block.

Trust us, you’ll be rethinking everything you thought you knew about autumn decor after this!

Sure! Here’s a casual, informal, and fun expansion of the first 20 fall scarecrow ideas:

1. Pose a scarecrow holding a pumpkin lantern

A photo of a rustic farmhouse entryway with a scarecrow holding a glowing pumpkin lantern. The scarecrow is wearing a straw hat and a plaid shirt. The background reveals a wooden fence and a pathway. The overall ambiance is warm and inviting.

Who says scarecrows can’t have jobs? Give your scarecrow a side hustle by having it hold a glowing pumpkin lantern. It’s a perfect mix of spooky and festive. Plus, it’ll light up your yard like a mini beacon of autumn goodness.

Your neighbors will be left wondering if the scarecrow is there to scare away birds or guide lost trick-or-treaters home. Either way, it’s a win. Bonus points if the pumpkin has a creepy face.

Don’t just stop at one lantern. Have your scarecrow hold a few, because in this economy, one gig isn’t enough.

2. Dress a scarecrow in flannel and overalls

A photo of a cottage-core backyard with a scarecrow dressed in flannel and overalls, propped up in a chair. The scarecrow is wearing a red and black flannel shirt, denim overalls, and a woolen cap. The scarecrow is placed near a small wooden table. The table is adorned with a few fall decorations, including a pumpkin, a gourd, and a few leaves. The background is a rustic wooden fence. The ground is covered with leaves. The lighting is soft.

Nothing screams “fall” like flannel. It’s cozy, it’s stylish, and—let’s be honest—who doesn’t love a scarecrow that looks like it just walked out of a lumberjack fashion show?

Toss in a pair of worn-out overalls, and you’ve got a scarecrow who’s not only working hard but looking the part. It’s farm-chic at its finest.

Just make sure you don’t accidentally grab your partner’s favorite flannel for this project. You will hear about it.

3. Perch a crow on the scarecrow’s shoulder/head

A photo of a living room in an English countryside house. There's a fake sinister-looking crow perched on the scarecrow's shoulder. The scarecrow is placed by a large glass window inside, where it can "watch" over things. The room has a rustic charm, with a wooden beam ceiling, a plush sofa, and a few chairs. There's a lamp near the sofa. The glass window has a few small flowers near the window. The floor is covered with a rug.

The irony here is delicious. Crows are supposed to be terrified of scarecrows, right? But nope, this crow is just chilling like it’s no big deal.

Perch a fake crow on the scarecrow’s shoulder or head to give your display some serious Halloween vibes. Bonus points if the crow looks extra sinister, like it’s plotting something.

It’s basically a scarecrow with a new BFF. We’re calling it: crows are the new black for fall decor.

4. Hang a scarecrow upside down from a tree

A photo of a scarecrow hanging upside down from a tree in front of an American home. The scarecrow is wearing a straw hat and a plaid shirt. The tree has orange and yellow leaves. The home has a white picket fence and is surrounded by a lawn. There are pumpkins and a wreath with a fall motif on the home's porch.

This one’s for the daredevils out there. Who says scarecrows have to stand upright? Suspend that bad boy upside down from a tree and let gravity do the talking.

Not only does this add a quirky twist to your yard, but it also gives off major “Is that scarecrow okay?” vibes. Spoiler alert: it’s not, and that’s the point.

It’s like your scarecrow went bungee jumping and forgot the “coming back up” part. Who knew fall could be so extreme?

5. Paint the scarecrow’s face with a friendly smile

A photo of a shabby chic living room with a scarecrow. The scarecrow has a friendly, goofy smile and is wearing a straw hat. There is a pumpkin next to the scarecrow. The room has a rustic wooden table, a woven rug, and a few vintage items. The walls have a beige hue and have a few decorations.

Sure, scarecrows are supposed to be spooky, but who says they can’t be nice, too? Paint a friendly, goofy smile on your scarecrow’s face. Nothing says “Welcome to my yard” like a scarecrow that looks like it just heard a really great joke.

This approach is perfect if you’ve got kids, or if you’re just not ready to fully embrace the creepy side of fall. Who could resist that charm?

Bonus: The birds might even stop and smile back. Or, you know, attack it—but hey, that’s nature.

6. Attach colorful fall leaves to the scarecrow’s hat

A photo of a fall-decorated traditional living room with a scarecrow near the fireplace. The scarecrow has a straw-filled body and a hat adorned with colorful fall leaves. The room has a wooden beam ceiling and a rustic mantle above the fireplace. There are pumpkins of various sizes on the floor and near the fireplace. The background contains a couch and a table with a lamp. The room has a warm, inviting ambiance.

Turn your scarecrow into a walking (or standing) celebration of fall by attaching a bunch of bright, colorful leaves to its hat. It’s like giving your scarecrow a makeover—fall edition.

Not only does this make your scarecrow look extra festive, but it also lets everyone know you’re all about those autumn aesthetics. You’re basically dressing your scarecrow better than you dress yourself, and that’s okay.

Pro tip: mix in real and fake leaves for that “I spent hours on this but totally didn’t” vibe.

7. Wrap the scarecrow in a scarf and mittens for a cozy look

A photo of a modern farmhouse living room decorated for fall. There's a scarecrow wrapped in a scarf and mismatched mittens near the door. The scarecrow is wearing a hat. The room has a beige sofa, a blue chair, a wooden coffee table, and a plant. There are pumpkins and a wreath on the wall. The floor is wooden. The lighting is warm.

Let’s be real: fall gets chilly. Even your scarecrow needs to bundle up! Wrap a cozy scarf around its neck and throw on some mismatched mittens for that extra touch of warmth.

Sure, it’s not actually cold out for the scarecrow, but hey, we’re going for aesthetics here. Plus, the more layers, the more stylish your scarecrow looks.

The best part? Your scarecrow might be warmer than you are when you’re out raking leaves.

Final Thoughts

We know, we know—some of these scarecrows are totally over the top, but isn’t that the point? Whether you’re looking for something funny, freaky, or just plain fabulous, these 7 ideas will give your fall decor the glow-up it deserves.

So go on, try a few, and prepare to have the most talked-about yard in the neighborhood. Just don’t blame us when your neighbors ask if they can borrow your scarecrow skills! 😎🍂